Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated in Bronx

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated in Bronx
3 / 5
49 reviews

1920 E Gun Hill Rd, Bronx, NY 10469-6014, Bronx

Overview

Cuisine
  • American
  • Diner

Restaurant Hours

Monday

08:00 - 17:00

Tuesday

08:00 - 17:00

Wednesday

08:00 - 17:00

Thursday

00:00 - 17:00

Friday

00:00 - 17:00

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
Tg
The greatest Ever
google
05.04.2024
1/5

This place is disgusting. Not only does it look ran down the windows are dirty the tables the bathroom was filthy. When I finally got my food it had a piece of hair in it!!!! They look like they just hire anybody off the street. Don't go unless you want food poisoning.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
KT
Kristen Tomaino
google
10.11.2018
4/5

The food is great. Not your usual diner fare. There are many multi-cultural dishes on the menu. The service is alright too.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
NJ
Noah Johnson
google
08.21.2018
3/5

Our waitress was fantastic. The food was not. Our Salmon Benedict was un-refined and bland with bad home fries, and the biscuits and gravy was one terrible biscuit with little gravy. The coffee was....coffee. Convenient parking though.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
AB
Andrew Brainard
google
08.15.2018
5/5

I had the lunch special, shank of lamb. Meat was falling off the bone. I enjoyed it very much. Our server was a little slow but she was very friendly and the rest of the staff made up for the inconvenience. I would definitely eat here again.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
AH
A-1 Handyman service david majors
google
08.02.2018
5/5

Good food at affordable prices very clean and nice workers

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
pj
paula james
google
07.27.2018
5/5

The wait staff are awesome. They greet you with a smile all the time. The food is prepared exactly as you ordered and the prices are reasonable. The ambiance and atmosphere make it a great diner.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
DF
Dnyce Fromdabx
google
04.25.2018
5/5

The food is good the customer service is good the vibe is pretty cool and they're open 24 hours you can't beat that. They might not have everything on the menu though so have a second option. If you need a venue to host a small event they have space for that.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
KC
Karim Cabrera
google
04.25.2018
4/5

Good visit, everything was good except for watery grits. Love the breakfast n lunch here.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
MK
Michael Khubba
google
04.04.2018
2/5

New owners supposedly. Caribbean waitresses. Service was ok but slow. Food was the same, but got pricey. They got order wrong, but was expected when my waitress first spoke. They are there for the black community now

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
VE
Veronica Ellis
google
03.23.2018
4/5

We went for breakfast on a Sunday morning. It was empty so we were seated quickly. We were greeted almost immediately by our server and started with just some coffee. We decided on scrambled eggs with cheese, grits and Canadian bacon. I asked for cheddar with my eggs but I don't think that's what I got. I only eat cheddar on my eggs so unless it was some exotic, overseas and organic cheddar, that wasn't cheddar. It was very bitter and tart and I just wound up scraping it off my eggs so I could get through my meal. It tasted between provolone ans swiss. But the rest of the meal was enjoyable. Despite the heat wave outside it was comfortable inside and as customers began to trickle in you could see this was a favorite local spot. The restroom was clean and well stocked with paper towels and tissue. And we were even gifted a small box of cookies when we left.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
DM
Dorian M
google
03.20.2018
4/5

The diner is permanently closed. The property was sold to developers in January for $10 million.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
JC
John Caraballo
google
03.06.2018
4/5

Good food at good prices that won't hurt your wallet. The wait staff is always eager to help with suggestions and substitutions. The bathrooms can be better maintained. Aside from what I mentioned all I can say is give them a try.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
GP
Gloria Pringle
google
03.03.2018
5/5

We had a great time and the food was good.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
MD
Michael Dean
google
02.17.2018
3/5

Stopped here for a bite to eat on the way home from NYC, it’s right off the highway. The service was ok. The place is a little odd. The staff was slow going with everything, but they did a good job of accommodating our requests eventually. The 3 stars is because all of the breakfast food is bland. The pancakes, omelettes, home fries, etc., all have very little flavor. Salt & pepper helps, but it’s all missing something. Overall, if you’re hungry and want decent food, this place is for you. If you have time, and a picky palette, perhaps look for a different diner.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
Kiwi875
google
01.18.2018
5/5

Great atmosphere. Good food.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
RL
Roan Lewis
google
10.11.2017
1/5

Oh boy oh oh boy. Where do i start. Overpriced food. I ordered a burger which i must say was not bad going down. But 10 minutes later sent me straight to the bathroom. Never going back ever again.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
MD
Mz Debi
google
10.03.2017
1/5

The wait service was very dissatisfying. The food was bland had no taste. I don't recommend this place to anyone.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
EP
Enid P.
google
08.18.2017
3/5

The omelette I ordered was an avocado, tomato, and cilantro omelette, but the chef doesn't add the cilantro because he doesn't want to. Otherwise, good place. Nothing special. Regular diner.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
JH
Jeffry Hill
google
07.27.2017
1/5

Ok so why are we sitting here and we still dont have our food never mind the fact that half the kitchen staff left for the day and we cant order what we want for dinner. The garnish is dead the corn looks sick the salmon was good (the one star) the mash potato was bland the windows are dusty and dirty the waitress is drunk just a bad experience all together come on guys do better. Oh before I forget I didnt know a salad consist of 3 tomatoes 3 cucumbers and 5 first fulls of lettuce.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
KR
Kareem Reem
google
07.27.2017
4/5

25 hour diner. Great if you wanna get get breakfast at the late hours after a club or bar. Prices are ok

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
RR
Robinson Roca
google
06.22.2017
4/5

Great food, service is good, I love the Bronx Special Breakfast, 3 meats, and your choice of Waffle, Pancakes, or French Toast.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
CC
Camille Chinea
google
06.18.2017
1/5

So I went and ordered some fries and mozzarella sticks and 1st the mozzarella sticks were undercooked and 2nd as I'm eating my fries I notice they tasted stale, then I notice towards the bottom of the aluminum plate some fries that had ketchup on them. I at no time put ketchup on my fries. They gave me someone's leftover stale French fries! I've been noticing that the quality of their food is decreasing steadily but this, this is an all time low for them, they have officially lost my business and I recommend that people just not waste their time or money at this diner anymore. Food prices are ridiculous and the food is definitely not worth getting someone's leftovers.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
kB
kay B
google
06.15.2017
3/5

This diner is good for sit downs, if you're looking for order and go DON'T DO IT...you pay same price for much shockingly smaller portions.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
MF
Martin Ferrer
google
05.05.2017
1/5

Got lost gettin in the parking lot. Place ended up bein closed. Its 3 am :/

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
GB
Glo Baby
google
05.03.2017
4/5

Would have gave them a 5 star but my streak was burned

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
SW
Selly Wares
google
04.04.2017
2/5

Pancakes are great. Home potatoes need work. Everything was over-priced. $32.28 for pancakes and a turkey sandwich

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
EF
Eliana Fernandez
google
03.23.2017
1/5

Besides the food being bland, my husband and I have never felt so uncomfortable. I believe it was the owner who came out and stared at us as if we were not gonna pay and just walk out of the restaurant. He did not leave at all until we left. Point being, I never ever leave reviews but we have never ever felt this uncomfortably. We are definitely not going back ever again. In the future, I hope people are treated with more respect and that he is at least discreet when securing the diner.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
SR
Shannon Rivera
google
03.15.2017
3/5

The food was ok, but not amazing. It was a little pricey considering.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
CP
Carol Pandy
google
03.03.2017
5/5

Best kept secret in the Bronx. Lee is the best waitress. The food and service is always excellent. I have been a customer for the past 20 yrs.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
GF
George F Boitano
google
02.24.2017
4/5

They could have added a little more sausage to my egg scramble, no big deal though. I liked to window paintings, very festive. The waiter was also very nice. I also liked to signed Jet's jersey even though I am a patriots fan.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
JC
Juan Carmona
google
02.13.2017
5/5

Good food, great service nice comfortable place. My son and I go here when I want to just enjoy a good meal and spend some time with him and not at home in front of the t.v. or on any other device.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
RV
Rich Vollenweider
google
01.05.2017
4/5

Decent food at a reasonable price

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
BZ
Banshegirl70 Za
google
11.27.2016
4/5

They offer grits with their breakfasts. Love grits & I don't know another diner in the neighborhood that offers grits.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
LA
Luz Algarin
google
11.23.2016
1/5

Only good thing in here was the waitress! She was very attentive but the breakfast here taste like hospital food.. Sorry my followers wish I could've said something positive about this diner but can't.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
TL
Tyrone Leader
google
11.22.2016
4/5

Good food and good service. Very spacious.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
JB
Jeanne Brennan
google
10.17.2016
4/5

Food and service very good. Able to accommodate large parties with little notice.A very good updated diner with extensive menu.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
FJ
Fernando Justiniano
google
08.15.2016
4/5

Great service good food will definitely recommend

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
SN
Salome N
google
08.01.2016
3/5

Good service, not bad diner but not good either. Food is ok. Prices are little higher.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
MB
Monique B.
google
07.04.2016
5/5

Great food and drinks. The portions are huge so you get a lot for your money. Staff is very attentive. Bathroom is also clean and there's free parking available.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
WP
William Portela
google
06.24.2016
4/5

Great for a late night meal stop in the Bx. It sits right off exit 10 on I-95 north. Not a truck stop, a family friendly environment.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
FC
Frankie C
google
05.19.2016
4/5

Good place nice service good no hony for yogurt but otherwise good atmosphere service excellence

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
BA
Bobby A. Green
google
05.10.2016
4/5

If you ever need to cater an event in the Bronx, this is that place. The food and service was top notch.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
AD
Anthony Diomede
google
04.21.2016
5/5

Nice diner, full menu plenty of parking. Food was good prices good. Staff friendly restaurant was clean. Rooms for parties on premises. Breakfast ,lunch, dinner, a nice place to dine for either

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
OC
Oneichan Critchlow
google
04.11.2016
3/5

The food was okay. But felt like something was lacking. But it was a family day so I got past the lacking part.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
MG
Marco Gonzalez
google
03.11.2016
2/5

Their service sucked, wait staff nowhere to be found when needing a refill of coffee. The waitress shirt was dirty n we were there bright and early for breakfast so the stains on her uniform were from days prior! Furthermore, the booths needed dusting. Place looks nice at first glance, however, once we were seated as we waited for our orders couldnt help but notice the dusty ledges n edges everywhere. The food was ok.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
LC
Leslie Carrington
google
03.09.2016
3/5

It was freezing in the place, and food had to go back because it was cold. That was just for the holiday so maybe things were pre done, but regular orders off menu was good. I would still eat on a regular day.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
JR
John Rossi
google
02.19.2016
3/5

Late night and convenient. Food is pretty good. I mostly order breakfast. The use to serve hashbrowns or French fries with their bronx breakfast. They since have stopped. What a bummer.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
DG
Deirdre Goss
google
02.11.2016
3/5

The table was dirty where they sat us. It was fully stocked but not clean and was broken. Just makes me Wonder if they have other things they don't clean. However, food is good. Menu lots of variety. Service is good too.

Pelham Bay Diner Incorporated
SS
Shatia Simmons
google
01.26.2016
1/5

Let me start off by saying this was 5am .The food was horrible😢😢 they only had one cook. I ordered the grits eggs and sausage platter the grits was watery and the cheese on the eggs was not sliced cheese it tasted like Velveeta spread . my stomach don't feel well after eating that food I would not recommend this Diner at all.

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 17183794130

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!